In a recent congressional hearing, former deputy national security adviser Matt Pottinger issued a stark warning to the political class: China has been stealthily waging a cold war against the United States for years. It is time to confront this reality and acknowledge that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is determined to overtake the U.S. and reshape the global order.
The Heritage Foundation’s special report, “Winning the New Cold War: A Plan for Countering China,” recognizes China as an adversary and outlines specific policy recommendations to address its growing threat. This report, divided into three parts, assesses the current state of the U.S.-China rivalry, identifies policy weaknesses, and offers strategies to protect America’s interests.
Part I of the report examines the strengths and weaknesses of both countries. It concludes that China is fully intent on surpassing the U.S. as the leading global power, consolidating control within the CCP, and increasing domestic repression. The U.S., on the other hand, faces internal challenges such as a declining military advantage and an overregulated economy. The report calls for a comprehensive approach to counter China’s ambitions.
Part II delves into specific fault lines within U.S.-China relations and offers over 100 policy recommendations. These include protecting the homeland from malicious Chinese activities, securing and advancing U.S. prosperity by reducing reliance on Chinese supply chains, reorienting America’s defense posture to deter Chinese dominance, diminishing the CCP’s influence and holding it accountable, and exercising global leadership through strategic alliances and partnerships.
The section on protecting the homeland suggests measures to crack down on illegal Communist Party operations within the U.S., restrict strategic land purchases by Chinese entities, and ban Chinese apps posing espionage risks. The section on securing and advancing U.S. prosperity highlights the need to scrutinize Chinese investments, reduce reliance on Chinese supply chains, and create a business environment that encourages companies to return to the U.S.
The section on reorienting America’s defense posture emphasizes the importance of prioritizing national security spending, strengthening deterrence in the Indo-Pacific, and rebalancing foreign assistance toward the region. The section on diminishing the CCP’s influence proposes measures to address trade practices that undermine U.S. prosperity, enhance export controls on sensitive technology, and investigate the origins of COVID-19. Lastly, the section on exercising global leadership calls for strategic actions in different regions to confront Chinese communist threats.
Part III focuses on the implementation of the plan, emphasizing the need for cooperation and coordination between various stakeholders, including the executive and legislative branches, federal agencies, state and local governments, U.S. allies, and the private sector.
The report underscores the urgency of the situation, emphasizing that the CCP aims to restructure the global order in its image. The stakes are high, and America’s future depends on effectively countering China’s aggression. However, engaging in a new cold war with China carries significant risks.
China poses a more formidable challenge than the Soviet Union did during the original Cold War. Its economy is on track to surpass America’s, and its military capabilities are growing rapidly. Moreover, China’s strategic partnership with Russia adds to its geopolitical leverage.
Unlike the bipolar world of the past, today’s global order is multipolar, making it harder for the U.S. to rally a preponderant coalition against its rivals. Countries like India, Indonesia, and Brazil are likely to remain nonaligned or even tilt toward China due to economic and geopolitical considerations.
Western democracies are grappling with internal divisions and are increasingly vulnerable to the appeal of populist leaders who espouse nationalist and protectionist policies. This erosion of political unity weakens the West’s ability to effectively confront the rising challenge from China.
Moreover, the technological landscape has drastically changed since the original Cold War. The interconnectedness and interdependence of the global economy make it difficult to isolate and contain a rival power like China. Supply chains stretch across borders, and economies rely on international trade and cooperation. Disrupting these networks in a new cold war would have far-reaching consequences, impacting not only the adversaries but also innocent bystanders caught in the crossfire.
The United States must invest in its own domestic renewal. By addressing internal challenges such as income inequality, education reform, and infrastructure modernization, it can bolster its economic resilience and enhance its capacity to compete on the global stage.
Ultimately, the goal should not be to defeat or suppress China but to shape its behavior and ensure that it operates within the bounds of international norms and rules. This requires a long-term and multifaceted approach that combines strength, agility, and strategic patience.
A new cold war between the United States and China is not predetermined, nor is it desirable. The consequences would be far-reaching and potentially catastrophic. Instead, the United States should draw upon its experience from the original Cold War, learn from its successes and failures, and adapt its strategy to the realities of the 21st century.
By embracing a nuanced approach that combines engagement, competition, and cooperation, the United States can navigate the complex dynamics of a rising China and safeguard its own interests and values. The future of the international order and the well-being of nations around the world depend on the choices made today. It is imperative that the United States leads with wisdom, foresight, and a commitment to peace and prosperity for all.